Category: Corporate & Commercial Litigation

The Uber Decisions: Justice Come Heller High Water? Litigating Unconscionability

Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb
David Marshall

July 14, 2020

The SCC decision in Uber v Heller raises questions about how unconscionability will be litigated and what evidence may be needed and admissible in such litigation.

Read more

The Uber Decision: Justice Come Heller High Water? Improvident Bargain

Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb
David Marshall

July 8, 2020

In Part 2 of our analysis on the recent decision of Uber v Heller, we discuss how the wide application of improvidence could lead to commercial uncertainty.

Read more

Pierringer Agreements and the Principle Against Overcompensation

Andrew Wilson

July 7, 2020

Notwithstanding a settling Defendants’ ostensible entitlement to a settlement surplus, the Court appears to have meaningfully limited the circumstances in which a settlement surplus will be recognized.

Read more

The Uber Decision: Justice Come Heller High Water? Unequal Bargaining Power

Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb
David Marshall

July 2, 2020

In the recent decision by the SCC in Uber v Heller, the majority confirms that the doctrine of unconscionability applies to all contracts. This undermines commercial certainty, as little guidance is provided for its application.

Read more

Contractual Interpretations and the "Surrounding Circumstances" - Six Years After Sattva

Ryan Phillips
Kaila Eadie

June 9, 2020

In the years since Sattva Capital Corp. v Creston Moly Corp. (2014), Canadian Courts have embraced the “modern” approach to contractual interpretation which requires a consideration of surrounding circumstances. That said, it is important not to stray too far from the words of the contract themselves.  

Read more

Are Contracts Enforceable Despite COVID-19? [Part 7]: Contract Law Meets Insolvency Law - Some Strategic Considerations

Christa Nicholson
Kaila Eadie

May 14, 2020

If your company has received, or may invoke, force majeure or frustration claims, it would be wise to consider both the law of contract and the possible impact of insolvency law.

Read more

Are Contracts Enforceable Despite COVID-19? [Part 6]: The Principles of Causation

Geoffrey Boddy
Kaila Eadie

May 7, 2020

Geoffrey Boddy and Kaila Eadie examine Canadian, American and British jurisprudence regarding the issue of causation for force majeure claims.

Read more

Are Contracts Enforceable Despite COVID-19? [Part 5]: Duty to Mitigate Force Majeure Events

Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb
William Katz

April 30, 2020

In Part 5 of our Enforceability of Contracts series, Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb and William Katz discuss the duty to mitigate the duration and effects of force majeure events.

Read more

Are Contracts Enforceable Despite COVID-19? [Part 4]: Force Majeure Notice Requirements

Geoffrey Boddy
Andrea MacLean

April 24, 2020

What does your contract say about notice requirements? Geoffrey Bodd and Andrea MacLean take a look at when a Court may, or may not, relax on notice requirements.

Read more

Tort Liability in a COVID World, Part 2: The Case of Walmart

Laura Warner
Sarah Bernamoff

April 17, 2020

Could your business be liable for failing to protect your employees and customers from COVID-19? Laura Warner and Sarah Bernamoff explore a recent lawsuit against and Arkansas Walmart and explain what businesses can do to protect themselves from liability.

Read more

Are Contracts Enforceable Despite COVID-19? [Part 3] Interpreting Force Majeure Clauses

Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb
Kaila Eadie

April 16, 2020

How do you interpret a force majeure clause? Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb and Kaila Eadie are your guides on interpreting force majeure clauses and the effect they will have on your business.

Read more

Are Contracts Enforceable Despite COVID-19? [Part 2]: The Applicable Legal Doctrines

Geoffrey Boddy
William Katz

April 9, 2020

“What happens if I don’t have a force majeure clause in my contract, is a frustration claim still possible?”

“What are the Applicable legal doctrines I can rely upon?”

Read more

Are Contracts Enforceable Despite COVID-19? [Part 1]: Overview

Bryan C. Duguid QC, FCIArb
Andrea MacLean

April 1, 2020

The Coronavirus has affected businesses both large and small, leaving many unable to fulfill their contractual obligations. So, what happens when, as a result of COVID-19’s impacts, a party has no choice but to breach a contract? Can parties be required to compensate for non-performance in this circumstance?  Is there some legal way out?

Read more

Social Distancing and Executing Documents with Electronic Signatures

Oliver Ho

April 1, 2020

How do you practice social distancing when documents need to be executed? Oliver Ho explores the legislation around using electronic signatures.

Read more